A UCC-1 financing statement is a legal form to record a secure transaction. It can present several challenges and potential problems if filed incorrectly or with incorrect information, including causing the creditor to lose priority over collateral. UCC-1 forms are usually filed with the Secretary of State’s office and include pertinent information, including debtor information, creditor information, and collateral. The UCC-1 financing statement establishes priority in the collateral over other creditors. The first creditor to file a UCC-1 has priority over others who file later or who don’t file should the debtor default.
Incorrect information
One of the most common mistakes creditors make when filing a UCC-1 financing statement is including incorrect information, including:
- Debtor’s Name: The debtor’s name must match the name on a government-issued identification. You cannot eliminate a middle name, misspell the name, or even add an extra space or period. Compare the name, spelling, and format of the name on government-issued identification with legal documents in the debtor’s name.
- Secured Party’s Name: Using the correct secured party’s name is also essential. If the secured party is a company, you must use the name as it appears on the Secretary of State’s records.
- Incorrect Addresses: To ensure proper notification and documentation, the debtor’s and creditor’s addresses must be correct. If you improperly enter the incorrect address, it could lead to delays and could create an imperfect lien.
- Typos and Inconsistencies: Another common error that could cause an imperfect lien is incorrectly spelling or incorrectly formatting names, addresses, and collateral.
You can help avoid these errors by using a professional lien-filing company. They can research the proper information, including legal names, company names, correct addresses, and jurisdiction.
Improper description of collateral
Using vague or overly broad collateral descriptions can lead to disputes about which assets the lien covers. Provide a clear and specific description, as courts use the description to identify collateral. Some things that will help when completing a UCC-1 financial statement include:
- Avoid Vague Descriptions: Avoid phrases such as “all assets” or “all personal property.” While these descriptions might seem comprehensive, they can be problematic as they are not specific enough to identify the collateral in the lien.
- Avoid Overly Broad Descriptions: Specifying “all inventory, equipment, and accounts receivable” covers too much and can be contested. Instead, be specific when listing assets used for collateral.
- Avoid Incomplete Descriptions: Include essential details, or you can weaken the security interest. For example, include VINs, year, make, and model of vehicles and serial numbers on other equipment.
- Avoid Inconsistent Descriptions: Ensure the descriptions you use in a UCC-1 financing statement match the descriptions of the collateral in related documents, including security agreements.
- Never Use Generic Descriptions: Avoid generic descriptions, such as “equipment” or “inventory.” List each item, including all inventory items.
Ensuring your descriptions are specific enough and match the security agreement helps decrease the risk of a UCC-1 filing being returned.
Failure to file timely
If you don’t file the UCC-1 financing statement on time, you can lose priority should the debtor default or file bankruptcy. UCC-1 filings are often subject to a “first to file” rule, so timing is critical.
Not only lenders have to file the UCC-1 financing statement as soon as possible, but they should also file a UCC-3 continuation statement within six months before the expiration date of the UCC-1 filing. Not filing a continuation can cause the security interest to lapse.
Lenders with many UCC-1 filings can easily slip through the cracks if they don’t monitor expiration dates.
The timely filing also includes updating the debtor’s and creditor’s information, including address changes, as delays can result in communication issues.
Not renewing the lien
UCC-1 filings have an expiration time – usually five years. If the lien is not renewed before the expiration date, the creditor can lose its priority status. Lenders must file a UCC-3 continuation statement to protect their security interests. If you miss the six-month window for filing the UCC-3 continuation statement, the creditor must refile a new UCC-1. The creditor also loses its original filing date priority.
Filing in the wrong jurisdiction
If a creditor files the UCC-1 financing statement in the wrong jurisdiction, it can invalidate the lien. Generally, the UCC-1 is filed where the debtor is located. Creditors must also know which office to file the UCC-1 statement. A significant error on the part of the creditor that files its own UCC-1 filings is filing in the wrong office for states that do not use the Secretary of State’s office for these filings.
The appropriate jurisdiction is usually the debtor’s state of residence for individuals. For a company, it is generally the state where it was incorporated or organized.
Some exceptions exist, including for debtors with multiple locations and foreign debtors. When a creditor files in the wrong jurisdiction, the UCC-1 financing statement may not be legally recognized, which causes an imperfect security interest.
Inadequate documentation
Each state has requirements regarding supporting documents. Failing to comply with these requirements can lead to a filing rejection or challenges if the debtor defaults.
Failure to notify relevant parties
Where states require it, creditors must notify debtors of the UCC-1 filing. Should the creditor fail to notify the debtor(s), it could cause legal issues or disputes.
Misunderstanding priority rules
Creditors need to understand the priority rules when filing UCC-1 financing statements, as it determines the order in which creditors are paid should the debtor file bankruptcy. The main rule is that the first creditor to file a UCC-1 has priority over others who file later. However, exceptions can affect priority, including:
- simultaneous interests
- purchase money security interests
- future advances
- subordination agreements
- cross-collateralization
Complex collateral structures
When the collateral is complex, such as creditors, including inventory, accounts receivable, or other assets that change over time, accurately describing and managing the lien is often challenging.
Creditors should ensure the description adequately describes complex assets and include future assets and subordination agreements.
Avoid mistakes by using a professional UCC filing service
Avoiding mistakes requires careful attention to detail and a thorough understanding of the UCC filing laws and procedures. Using a professional lien-filing service with experience handling these complex filings can help ensure the process is completed correctly, and creditors maintain their security interests in collateral.
